CORIMO

LMU’s Coronavirus Infection Risk Monitoring (CORIMO) program evaluated the effectiveness of individual pandemic measures, such as closures and contact restrictions, as part of a questionnaire-based study.

Contact

Verena Hoffmann
PD Dr. Verena S. Hoffmann

Lead of RG Clinical Data Science

CORIMO - COVID-19 Infection Risk Monitoring

LMU’s COVID-19 Infection Risk Monitoring (CORIMO) evaluated the effectiveness of individual pandemic measures, such as closures and contact restrictions. To do this, we asked people who came to the testing center at Theresienwiese in Munich to take a PCR test to fill out a questionnaire. In this questionnaire, participants were able to provide information about their activities and living conditions over the past 8 days.
Using this information, the study team analyzed which circumstances were more common among people infected with COVID-19 than among those who tested negative. At the same time, the study tracked currently in-effect protective measures—such as mandatory mask-wearing, restrictions on the number of people at gatherings, “appointment shopping,” etc.—as well as the proportion of vaccinated individuals, in order to assess their impact.
The data was analyzed weekly to provide timely information. The questionnaire was also updated weekly to reflect the current measures.
CORIMO is funded by the State Office for Health and Food Safety.

Background

Since SARS-CoV-2 first appeared in Germany in March 2020, its spread has been slowed by measures such as the closure of educational and cultural institutions and large portions of the retail sector, as well as contact restrictions—some of which were far-reaching. The package of measures as a whole was able to significantly reduce case numbers; however, it remains largely unknown which specific measures are helpful and which are ineffective for infection control. According to the RKI, the source of infection is known for only about one-quarter of those who tested positive (Fig.1 (PDF, 74 KB)), primarily because even asymptomatic individuals can transmit the virus. The route of transmission is usually known only in the case of outbreaks in private households, nursing homes, and senior living facilities, as well as in shared housing.

(Fig.1) Breakdown of reported COVID-19 cases by setting and reporting week, as assigned to an outbreak by the respective public health department. All cases from outbreaks with 2 or more cases are shown. The possible settings are specified as categories in the query.

The easing of restrictions in the summer led, with a time lag, to a sharp rise in case numbers in the fall. Once again, it remained unclear which specific easing measures were the main drivers of the spread.
Restrictions will continue to be necessary until enough people in Germany have been vaccinated to allow the pandemic to subside. To minimize social and economic damage as much as possible, the measures implemented must be precisely targeted. Furthermore, the effectiveness of the measures put in place must be well-documented in order to maintain trust in policymakers and government officials and to dispel any suspicion of arbitrariness. Concrete information about the risks also makes it easier for citizens to avoid risky situations and opt for less risky alternatives.

Results

During the survey period from May 20, 2021, to June 30, 2022, a total of 10,106 questionnaires were completed and marked with a barcode so that they could be linked to the results of the PCR test.
All adults who underwent a PCR test at the testing center were eligible to participate in CORIMO. The CORIMO sample consisted primarily of young (81.9% under 45 years old), well-educated (62.8% with a college degree, another 21.6% with a high school diploma) individuals with sufficient monthly disposable income (47% earning more than 2,000 euros per month).
Figure 3 (PDF, 25 KB) graphically illustrates the proportions of positive and negative test results over the recruitment period, as well as the various access restrictions for the PCR test.

In accordance with the access restrictions, the study was divided into three analysis periods.
The results from the first analysis period are the most reliable, as PCR testing was not yet contingent on a specific suspicion of infection.
For this period (May 20, 2021, to September 13, 2021), 4,165 questionnaires were collected. Of these, 87 had a positive test result (2.1%).
Overall, 9.8% of participants had had known contact with an infected person in the past 8 days; of these, 4.3% were personal contacts, 3.9% were work-related contacts, and 1.6% were household contacts. There were significantly more infections when there had been (known) contact with an infected person (OR 6.81 [4.34 – 10.56]). The risk was particularly high for contacts within one’s own household (OR 13.41 [6.32 – 26.42]) and in private settings (OR 9.29 [5.32 – 15.72]). For contacts in the workplace, the risk was elevated, though not significantly so (OR 1.84 [0.55 – 4.58]).

Wearing a mask when in contact with an infected person significantly reduced the risk of infection (OR 0.33 [0.12–0.77]). In the workplace, masks were worn more frequently during contact with infected individuals (99 out of 156 contacts, 63.5%) than in private settings (35 out of 173 contacts, 20.2%) and at home (12 out of 62 contacts, 19.4%).
A higher number of people (OR 1.00 [0.84–1.18]) in the participants’ households did not lead to a significantly higher number of infections. Similarly, whether children lived in the household (OR 1.04 [0.54–1.87]) and whether these children attended a daycare center, elementary school, or secondary school was not a determining factor for infection status.

During the analysis period, strict contact restrictions were in place at times (until June 1, 2021: a maximum of 5 people from a maximum of two households; until June 30, 2021: a maximum of 10 people from a maximum of three households; as of July 1, 2021: no restrictions). Under these restrictions, there were relatively few private indoor contacts (median 3 [IQR 1–7]) and relatively few private contacts overall (median 6 [IQR 4–10]). In the context of all additional measures, these contacts did not lead to more frequent infections (OR for private indoor contacts 0.99 [0.96–1.02], OR for private contacts in general 1.0 [0.99–1.02]).
Under the comprehensive hygiene measures in effect at the time (such as 3G, limits on visitor or participant numbers, and mandatory mask-wearing), other leisure activities—such as group sports or working out at the gym, attending movies, theaters, or concerts (indoors, with assigned seating), or visiting playgrounds in the 8 days prior to the PCR test—did not lead to a significant increase in the OR for infection. The same applies to visits to restaurants and cafés.

People who shopped in stores more frequently or visited a hair salon (including beauty salons and pedicure salons) were not infected at a higher rate. Here, too, extensive measures were in place during this period, such as limiting the number of customers based on store size, a mask mandate, and, at times, an appointment-only policy for stores that did not sell daily necessities.
The use of local public transit, as well as travel by train and airplane, also showed no impact on infection rates. Face masks were required on all modes of transportation throughout the entire analysis period.

Of the respondents, 3,182 (76.4%) had worked at least one day in their profession during the past 8 days. On a median basis, respondents reported having worked in their profession on 5 days (IQR 2–6) during the past 8 days. On a median basis, two of those days were spent on-site at the workplace (e.g., office, workshop; IQR 0–5) and two were spent working from home (IQR 0–5). Of the 2,178 participants who had not worked exclusively from home, 1,685 reported having shared their workspace with at least one other person. The median number of people with whom participants worked in a room was 2 (IQR 0–4). Among the 1,643 participants who reported having had contact with customers/students/clients, the median number of such contacts per day was 5 (IQR 3–15). Among participants with customer contact, 80.6% reported wearing a mask most of the time or always when in contact with customers.
While working from home for more days showed no protective effect (OR 0.98 [0.89–1.09]), the risk of infection for working adults with customer contact was significantly increased if they rarely or never wore a mask (OR 3.125 [1.47–6.67]).
The question regarding vaccination status was introduced on July 5, 2021, and was answered by 2,896 participants. Of these, 499 participants (17.2%) reported being unvaccinated, 614 (21.2%) had received the first of two vaccine doses, and 1,783 (61.6%) were fully vaccinated. Having received at least one vaccine dose provided significant protection against infection (OR 0.39 [0.25–0.64]).

The full RKI situation report in German can be viewed here (PDF, 3,063 KB).

Partner